Christian Cole holds all the school rushing records with 383 in a game, 3,252 in a season and 5,070 in a career. His other records include 47 touchdowns in a season and 68 in a career.

Tight end Ben Koyack is the only Oil City High School graduate (2011)  to play in the NFL. After setting numerous receoving records in high school, he played his college ball at Notre Dame.

Mark Kulinski, another 2011 grad, holds the three main school passing records with 444 yards in a game, 3,253 yards in a season and 6,045 yards in a career.